Friday, January 25, 2008

Public Schools VS Public Libraries

"The State...has a vested interest in promoting attitudes that would tend to make us skeptical of our own abilities, fearful of the motives of others, and emotionally dependent upon external authorities for purpose and direction in our lives."
-- Butler D. Shaffer, from Americans for Limited Gov't. Mar 15, 06


When a US citizen enters a public library, the library employee's attitude is, "How can I help you? What are you interested in? How can I satisfy your curiosity? What information can I help you find? All of our resources are at your disposal," etc.

Librarians don’t ask probing questions of their patrons, whatever their age; they do not judge their patrons' abilities or qualifications. They are there to help them in their interests, whatever they might be. Librarians never look at a child and say, "You're too young to want to learn about that" or, "You should wear proper clothes to come here" or, "You are not qualified to read that book." etc

But when a child enters a public school, the attitude of the employees is entirely different. The teachers typically demand that children "Sit down; be quiet, think only what I tell you to think. Never mind your personal interests, never mind your curiosity, do not ask questions...we will ask the questions for you to answer." etc.

The school employees see children as "resources" that can be used for the school's purposes. Thus, they see the children as a commodity to be exploited -- used for the benefit of the school, not as patrons to be served. Their attitude is, "How can I use this child (and his/her parents) to make me look good; to enlarge the school budget; hire more teachers; increase state funding," etc.

The state, too, sees public school children as economic units, cogs in the social machinery, in short: slaves to the state. Remember that the public school system is a politically controlled arm of the state.

The schools have a similar approach to parents, seeing them as willing or potential participants in the teacher union’s plans to raise teacher pay, increase budgets, hire more union employees, spend more tax money, saying that it’s "all for the children," of course. Meanwhile, the employees almost never accede to the wishes of parents regarding school programs or policies.

Thus, libraries exist to serve the patrons -- whoever they are, whatever their age or politics or circumstances, however they are dressed. But the government schools exist to exploit citizens and their children for the benefit and convenience of their employees. By their actions and intentions, we can see that schools exist also for the state education bureaucracy, and assorted politicians at all levels – not for children, parents or the community.

Who would use a library that treated patrons the way schools do? Wouldn’t it be better if schools were more like libraries?

9 comments:

R said...

This is so true, Ned. And may be why children seem to want and enjoy going to the library- but resent and fight going to school. My kids, at least, could go 2-3 times a week.

christinemm said...

Sadly in my town they keep taking money away from the public library. In contrast the money to the elementary school and that one library goes up and up.

We lost a great children's librarian from the public library who went to work for the public elementary school in the same town as the pay was higher. Sigh. It is interesting to ponder how the pay can be higher for a school librarian who works just 180 days a year, has summers off, and is being paid technically by the same town budget.

Later we had to fight to get a replacement children's librarian at the public library.

I wrote my first and only letter to the Selectmen in support of hiring a replacement children's librarian. A year later the education budget was tried to be raised by 11% and my husband wrote a letter to the Selectmen to oppose it. He got a response from our registered party's opposition who was the Second Selectman. It was very rude and said that my husband should go speak to his wife about her feeling of wanting to have a healthy library budget and that if we are so concerned with saving money then I should not want the public library to keep a children's librarian. You see in my town they keep track of these things and they snap back at you if you speak out.

(The little town newspaper complains that they can't get our citizens to share opinions and speak out on things like the rising education budget. My friend whose kids are in school says all the parents are afraid to speak out with anything negative at all lest their child be blackballed by being forever doomed to go into the 'worst teachers classroom'.

Anyhow..
You should see the elementary school's wonderful library. It is breathtaking.

I feel that the public library serves all patrons and should be there for all of us. The public school teachers are also allowed to borrow books from the public library as of course are the public schooled children. It is not like the public library is not there for the students or the teachers.

Additionally the trend is around here the elementary classrooms have full libraries in each, hundreds of books so that the teachers don't even need to use the school's own library. I have been told by teachers that they barely use the school library instead they want to own their own mini-libraries in their own classrooms. The children can read what is right in the classroom and it is convenient.

And I still don't get why some teachers say they pay out of their own pocket to supply their own classroom with new books. Yet at the end of the year these books stamped with the school or class information are discarded into the town's library sale or end up in used book stores.

I don't get it at all.

Ned Vare said...

Christine,
The answer is corruption. Armand Fusco's book, "School Corruption," calls public schools, "a culture of deceit and corruption."
In my town, the town library gets about $20K per year from taxes for new books. It serves the town of 25,000 people, and is open nights and weekends. Meanwhile, the school libraries (there are several) get about four times as much for books while serving only 4000 kids, and none are open after school hours. It is another outrage.

About This Site said...

As a public youth librarian, let me say that I am flattered by your opinion of my profession. However, as a former teacher, I feel obligated to say that most teachers really do care a great deal for the students they teach. There are a few who are either lazy or burnt out (as there are in any profession), but the great majority of teachers are self-sacrificing saints. Suffice it to say that they are doing more and more with less and less. Things do need to change, I believe education in our country is in the toilet, but teachers don’t deserve all the blame.

Our schools simply reflect our society. If you don’t know what I mean, go volunteer at your local schools so you can learn first hand why things are the way they are.

vfdvgf said...

Your Best final fantasy gil Choice! last chaos money wow gold last chaos money withage of conan gold and aoc goldor FFXI Gil link lord of the rings gold The World world of warcraft power leveling Leading last chaos money andKnight Online Noah

King Bayern Munich said...

This is a great article, supplies the useful information for me, thanks in this
soft sofa
Modern-stone-sculpture
billiards
Long span shelving
baby stroller
oil paintings
outdoor ceramic tiles
casual shoes
oil paintings

luck said...

Importantly make sure the Nike Air Max are very good vibrates resistancewe.Nike Air Max 91 with Nike shoe sole for traction technology and physical mobility Nike Free technology.TheNike Air Max Shoes is a beautiful ship and very flawless.The shoes Nike Air Max Boots hovercraft significantly in the heel which is visible side of the base on most models.the design using cotton lining inspired Leahter feet. There are more and more popular, the success is to make materials and design feature styles. Nike Shoes Us is worth buying, rushed to use the time for direct purchase, brings great joy to you.

lily said...

What do you observe when you meet a person for the first time? Does a dress or stylish jewelry look good? Do you think shoes carry out a healthy impression particularly to those who judge people with their shoes they usually prefer to wear? Well, shoes are really very important to bring out an overall good impact. Nike Shoes are liked and recognized all over the world.
Nike Shoes Us
We provide products of
Nike Air Max 1
Air Max Griffey 1
Nike Air Max 180
Nike Air Max 2009
Nike Air Max 2010
Nike Air Max 24 7
Nike Air Max 87
Nike Air Max 2011
Nike Air Max 90
Nike Air Max 91
Nike Air Max 95
Nike Air Max BW
Nike Air Max Plus TN
Nike Air Max LTD
Nike Air Max Boots
Nike Air Max Presto
Nike Air Max Skyline
Nike Air Max Turbulence
Nike Air Max Fitsole
Nike Air Max Goadome
Nike Air Max Zenyth
Nike Air Max Wildwood Supreme
Nike Air Max Zoom Kobe
Nike Air Max Shoes
Buy Nike Air Max
Christian Louboutin Outlet
Nike Outlets

Latest nike shoes said...

This Nike soccer cleats ultra vibrant New nike soccer shoes ...The Nike soccer cleats has a huge army of fans across the globe, and if you're one of them we know you love them to be bright, flashy and in-your-face colours. Checking out these nike mercurial vapor superfly III fg versions, part of Nike's Fall seasonal releases, we're sure you're going to love these Nike Football Cleats too, they combine Laser technology and Nike Mercurial Vapor Superfly with the Vapor series!especially once they start appearing en masse on pitch. You can click "VIEW MORE" for more detailed pictures. New levels of performance after nike mercurial vapor superfly III new levels of performance after.